West would later go on to head the Violence Project at UCLA, where he and Dr. James Hamilton, an OSS colleague of George White and a recipient of CIA largesse, performed psychological research involving behavior modifications on inmates at Vacaville state prison in northern California. Early years and education. The CIA did know of several test victims who took themselves or were taken to hospitals in the San Francisco area. Although, of course, he never knew that name. how did sidney gottlieb die. Gottlieb's contribution was to oversee MKUltra. The man with the clubfoot also spent his time folk-dancing, and, having suffered his entire life from a bad stutter, also completed a masters degree in speech therapy. The secretive scientist who only had one known picture of himself was hired in 1951 by Allen Dulles, who would later . This rivaled anything in Dachau. At least 40 wives of those enrolled had been diagnosed with the disease, and . The project, called MKUltra, began in 1953, two years after Gottlieb had joined the agency as chief of its technical services division. Allen eventually became disappointed with the research into hypnosis, and developed a keen interest in the more robust fields of electro-shock therapy and psycho-surgery. The hope was that they could be prompted in this manner to attack each other. In 1951, Gottlieb joined the Central Intelligence Agency. For twenty years, he was the senior scientist. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. He died in 2008 at the age of 102 . He worked as a member of the Technical Services Staff (TSS) and eventually became head of the Chemical Division. Eventually Earman wrote a 24-page report for McCone in which he harshly denounced the drug-testing program, which he said put the rights and interests of all Americans in jeopardy. Helms and Gottlieb fiercely defended MK-ULTRA to McCone, with Helms raising the spectre of a Soviet chemical gap, claiming that widespread testing was necessary to keep pace with Soviet advances. In July 1968 a team of CIA psychologists set up shop at Bien Hoa Prison outside Saigon, where NLF suspects were being held after Phoenix Program round-ups. On March 7, 1999, Sidney Gottlieb, who over a period of some two decades oversaw much of the CIA's research and at times operations involving "mind control" and poisons, died at the age of 80. He graduated. You killed your mother. When Loguey went home, he was shocked to discover that his mother was alive and apparently well. In his way Sidney Gottlieb was a loyal servant of American government - but his ways differed only in degree from the experiments for which the wartime allies, among them the US, sent Nazi doctors to the gallows for crimes against humanity. McDonald was a 25-year-old mother of five young children. He also investigated the practical benefits of inducing paralysis in some of his patients by giving them injections of curare. TSD was tasked with providing case officers with . In 1971, Estabrooks gave a chilling portrait of his career in an article in Science Digest titled Hypnosis Comes of Age. One of the most fascinating but dangerous applications of hypnosis is its use in military intelligence, Estabrooks wrote. The code-name ULTRA may have been an echo from Helmss and Dulless OSS days, when ULTRA (the breaking of the primary German code) represented one of the biggest secrets of World War II. Then Estabrooks described how he and other government doctors developed techniques to split personalities, using a combination of hypnosis and drugs. He was even, by . In 1952, the codeword Bluebird was changed to Artichoke. In these instances a certain modicum of informed consent was often required. At the end of it all, just as the conspiracy theorists would have predicted, Gottlieb himself pronounced that the entire exercise had been a waste of time. So did Robert Hunter, the lyricist for the Grateful . It kept him out of World War II, but it did not stop him from practicing folk dancing, a lifelong passion. He then moved back to rural Virginia, where he indulged two longstanding hobbies, folk dancing and goat herding. The public disclosure of the MKULTRA program in the 1970s during Senate investigations of CIA activities and the program's further exploration in John Marks's 1978 book The Search for the "Manchurian Candidate": The CIA and Mind Control had both political and cultural ramifications. how did sidney gottlieb die. He made pills, powders, and potions that could kill or maim without a traceincluding . Its cruel, its idiotic, its unspeakably horrible. In the early 1990s, Ed was an early supporter of our environmental rag, Wild Forest Review, and invited me to start writing for Lies of Our (ie., NY)Times. As reported by multiple sources, Clark was neither arrested nor prosecuted for the murder. The visionary chemist Sidney Gottlieb was the CIA's master magician and gentlehearted torturerthe agency's "poisoner in chief.". The CIA memos of the time are filled with complaints about the difficulties of finding suitable human subjects for experimental research. He also volunteered at a hospice. By the early 1970s, the CIAs dirty tricks came under increasing press and congressional scrutiny, and in 1973 agency director Richard Helms gave the order to destroy most of the extant records of the MK Ultra program. In addition to administering high doses of LSD, he subjected people to psychological torture, including electroshock therapy. Kinzer describes the Poisoner-in-Chief's hand in the assassination of . He was born in 1918 the son of Hungarian Jewish immigrants, but never adopted the faith; indeed much of the rest of his life was a search for religious fulfilment, via agnosticism, Christianity and even Zen Buddhism. CIA Sidney Gottlieb, the man who oversaw all of the project MK-Ultra mind-control experiments. Born with a clubfoot and afflicted with a severe stammer, Gottlieb pushed himself with unremitting intensity. Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in, Please refresh your browser to be logged in, Extra 20% off selected fashion and sportswear at Very, Up to 20% off & extra perks with Booking.com Genius Membership, $6 off a $50+ order with this AliExpress discount code, 10% off selected orders over 100 - eBay discount code, Compare broadband packages side by side to find the best deal for you, Compare cheap broadband deals from providers with fastest speed in your area, All you need to know about fibre broadband, Best Apple iPhone Deals in the UK March 2023, Compare iPhone contract deals and get the best offer this March, Compare the best mobile phone deals from the top networks and brands. The MK-ULTRA projects were not limited to research on adults. James Bond had Q, the scientific wizard who supplied 007 with dazzling gadgets to deploy against enemy agents. . Cameron was eased out of his post at Allan Memorial in 1964 and died of a heart attack while mountain climbing in 1967 at the age of sixty-six. Who wouldnt be afraid of a pack of damned hyenas? The recklessness of the program helped to motivate the creation of new intelligence oversight structures. White called this enterprise Operation Midnight Climax. Prisoners could get reduced sentences for agreeing to participate in the experiments. In fact, US military and intelligence agencies had been dabbling in mind control research for more than forty years. As head of the MK-ULTRA mind control project, he directed brutal experiments at secret prisons on three continents. He completed his doctorate in biochemistry at California Institute of Technology. June 11, 2022 . Sidney Gottlieb. In 2017, he was portrayed by actor Tim Blake Nelson in Errol Morris . Degrowth or Debunk: Do Degrowth proponents have a strategy? He was 94. The CIA had become increasingly frustrated with its inability to break down suspected NLF leaders by using traditional means of interrogation and torture. It was a period when paranoia ruled at Langley, the Virginia headquarters of the CIA. Haaretz.com, the online English edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, gives you breaking news, analyses and opinions about Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World. I had no identity, no memory. He had not told new agency director John McCone about the program, and he double-crossed Earman on a promise to do so. As soon as the story hit the paper it was yesterdays news, and we waited and waited for real congressional hearings and we waited for the lists of people who were victims to be notified. SIDNEY GOTTLIEB was living vindication for conspiracy theorists that there is nothing, however evil, pointless or even lunatic, that unaccountable intelligence agencies will not get up to in the pursuit of their secret wars. Many Democrats . Like Frank Olson, it was not officially revealed whether or not the death had been a suicide (p. 259). Within Technical Services MK-ULTRA projects came under the control of the Chemical Division, headed from 1951 to 1956 by Dr. Sidney Gottlieb, a New York Jew who received his doctorate in chemistry from California Tech. But the mild-mannered meditator also had a covert killer side to him. As he said, "I was in prison for committing a crime, but they committed a greater crime on me.". He also enjoyed a long relationship with US intelligence agencies dating back to World War II, having been brought to Nuremberg by Allen Dulles to help evaluate Nazi war criminals, most notably Rudolf Hess. These experiments ended in failure, leaving the prisoners to became little more than lab material for experiments. Like Frank Olson, it was not officially revealed whether or not the death had been a suicide (p. 259). He made pills, powders, and potions that could kill or maim without a traceincluding . Wed 10 Mar 1999 20.28 EST. Earman probed deeper, unearthing what he swiftly concluded was an illegal, indeed criminal, venture. This is a field with which I am familiar through formulating guidelines for the technique used by the US in two world wars. The period was one of extreme fear almost paranoia among U.S. officials, from the double threat of the Communist regimes in the Soviet Union and China. Estabrooks was a Rhodes scholar who had trained in psychology at Harvard with Gardner Murphy. He was interrogated, hypnotized, and given a polygraph and truth serum. From the early 1950s through most of the 1960s hundreds of American citizens were administered mind-altering drugs. The therapeutic sessions were filmed and passed along for viewing by Himmler. Theyre Doing it in the USA Too, On False Hopes and Broken Promises: Behind the Scenes of the UN Statement on Palestine, A Conversation With Keith Lamar, From Death Row in Ohio, The Nightmare of Great Power Rivalry Over Taiwan, Left to Die: Deterrence, Death, and Rescue in the Borderlands, Japan to Delay Ocean Dumping of Contaminated Waste Water from Fukushima, A Socialist Survival Tactic: Cubas Worker Parliaments, Politics In the Catastrophe, the Elders Calling, The Deafening Silence of Intellectuals in the Face of Growing Global Conflicts, Women Wont Renegotiate Our Place in the Economy, Land for Peace: Borders Arent Sacred, Human Lives Are, Workers, Machines, and Bonus Depreciation, The Abstainers: What Biden Left Out of His Warsaw Speech, When Companies Hire Low-Wage Contractors, They Put My Life at Risk, Humanitys Secret War Against the Environment, Ourselves, and Our Children, Before Norfolk Southern Poisoned Ohio, It Poisoned the Statehouse, Reconciliation Does Not Mean Forgetting in Nicaragua, Its Time to Realize the Farm Bills Transformative Potential, Why News of Population Decline and Economic Slowdown Isnt Necessarily a Bad Thing, Doing Washingtons Bidding: Australias Treatment of Daniel Duggan, Remembering Kuwasi Balagoon and the Forgotten Legacy of Black Anarchism, Prairie Populist, Honest Senator James Abourezk, Fearless Fighter for Justice, Why Biden Snubbed Chinas Ukraine Peace Plan, ILWU Alums Tackle Labor Power and Strategy Questions. No peaceful settlement has ever been agreed upon. Gottlieb distributed it to hospitals and other institutions under the guise of fake foundations. He once locked a woman in a small white box for thirty-five days, where she was deprived of all light, smells and sounds. Sidney was born in the Bronx under the name Joseph Scheider. After getting a doctorate in biochemistry from California Institute of Technology in 1940, he married Margaret Moore, who had been born in India. He attended City College in New York, Arkansas Polytechnic, and graduated with a bachelors degree in chemistry from the University of Wisconsin in 1940. Directed by Sidney Gottlieb, experiments took place across America in colleges, prisons, and mental institutions, as well as internationally in Canada and Europe. Their house was a former slave quarters, and Gottlieb rose every morning before sunrise to milk his herd of goats. The son of Hungarian Jewish immigrants, Gottlieb excelled in the sciences at City College. During a 1953 meeting at a mountain retreat with MK . It wasnt long before the CIA researchers carried their investigations beyond the safehouse on Telegraph Hill. He was portrayed by Tim Blake Nelson in Errol Morris Wormwood in 2017, which was based on the death of Frank Olson who was connected to Gottlieb and died under mysterious circumstances. Amid these security lapses, the Security branch lost control of research, which now passed to Covert Operations, and eventually into the hands of Dr. Gottlieb. But, as John Marks, author of The Search for the Manchurian Candidate: the CIA and mind control (1979), the definitive work on the subject, wrote: "He never did what he did for inhumane reasons. As director of TSD, Sid was like the character "Q" in the James Bond movies. Isbell developed a points system to secure their cooperation in his research. One of his subjects was a young creative writing student at Stanford, Ken Kesey, who would become the drugs chief proponent in the sixties counterculture. From the beginning, MK-Ultra's mind-control experiments were conducted with great secrecy in part because the CIA was well aware of the dubious ethics involved. Dr. Scott Gottlieb was sworn in as the 23rd commissioner of Food and Drugs on May 10, 2017. Gottlieb was involved in assassination attempts during the Eisenhower and Kennedy administrations, developing unconventional weapons, including a poison handkerchief to kill an Iraqi colonel, poison gifts for Fidel Castro, and a poison dart to kill a leader in the Congo. There Thornwell was secretly given LSD over a period of several days by army and CIA interrogators, during which he was forced to undergo extremely aggressive questioning, replete with racial slurs. For two decades he ran a CIA programme aimed at nothing less than control of the human mind. Helms told McCone that positive operational capacity to use drugs is diminishing owing to a lack of realistic testing., McCone put a freeze on CIA-sponsored testing at the safe-houses, but they remained open for George Whites use with the CIA paying the bills until 1966, when White retired. Later, back in Virginia, where he owned a 15-acre goat farm, he worked with dying people in a hospice, and tried to organize a commune. His death was announced on Friday by the . This answer is: So did Robert Hunter, the lyricist for the Grateful Dead, which went on to become a great purveyor of LSD culture. Your own man may have unquestionable loyalty but his judgement is always open to question. Prisoners were also given LSD, notably Whitey Bulger, who volunteered for what he thought were experiments to find a cure for schizophrenia. All right, Ill tell you. The doctor assured her husband that Cameron was the best there was and would have her back home and healthy in no time. Ed passed in his sleep at age 92, his mind still as sharp as ever, his spirit fiercely defiant. According to detailed account in the Artichoke files, the entire operation was conducted on the second floor of the safehouse, so as not to arouse the curiosity of the household staff and security detail.. My medical file even says I took my guitar with me. At least one "participant" died as a result of the experiments and several others went mad. I thought in 1978 when our books were appearing, when we were doing media work all over the world, that we would finally get the story out, the vaults would be cleansed, the victims would learn their identities, the story would become part of history, and the people who had been injured could seek recompense, recalled Alan Scheflin. Dr. Sidney Gottlieb (Sid) was a scientist and chemist working for the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) that ran the Technical Services Division (TSD) and before that position he ran the Chemical Division within TSD. There was a problem, however. This mind control research was dubbed Artichoke.. Bulger would eventually write about his experiences, which he described as horrifying. In the early 1960s, the CIA even helped set up a company to scour the Amazon for potential new drugs, the Amazon Natural Drug Company. After these mishaps, Gottlieb became persuaded that the best course was simply to test the hallucinogens on a random basis at public gatherings, or to pick out street people and induce them to swallow a dram of whatever potion was under review that day. Allen Ginsberg, the poet who preached the value of the great personal adventure of using LSD, got his first LSD from Sidney Gottlieb. Ken Kesey, Allen Ginsberg, and Robert Hunter were among the users of the drug that became part of the rebellion for their generation. The LSD safehouse program continued in both New York and San Francisco until 1963, when the CIAs new Inspector General, John Earman, stumbled across the enterprise. The broad outlines of Gottlieb's story have been public for years. The conviction and apparent sincerity with which an individual will defend a false given under post-hypnotic suggestion is almost unbelievable.. The C.I.A., convinced that its enemies had developed a method to control human minds, developed MKUltra to find its own techniques until the 1960s, inspired by the work of Japanese and Nazi scientists. Source: (wikipedia), Tim Blake Nelson who portrayed him in Wormwood. White would sit on the lavatory, martini in hand, watching prostitutes give CIA designer drugs to their unsuspecting clients. Then in 1957 Cameron found a new stream of money, Gottliebs MK-ULTRA accounts. Major newspapers ran obituaries when he died in 1999. Hotly pursued by CIA colleagues, he fled across a bridge over the Potomac and was finally cornered, crouching in a fetal position near Arlington National Cemetery.. In 1951, he was recruited by the CIA, where he was appointed head of the technical services staff of the chemical division. Gottlieb then gave the green light for CIA station officers in Manila and Atsugi, Japan, to begin the operational use of LSD. Unsurprisingly, it was soon discovered that the clients were more likely to talk after sexual activity. Lobotomies were another area of intense interest for Dr. Cameron, who instructed his psycho-surgeons to perform their operations using only mild local anesthetics. Green. In the divisions laboratories and workshops researchers labored on poisons, gadgets designed to maim and kill, techniques of torture and implements to carry such techniques to agonizing fruition. Sidney Gottlieb, the child of Hungarian immigrants, was born on August 3, 1918. He also had a club foot. Gottlieb was the first LSD maven, the original acid visionary. Gottlieb believed that, to control minds, he would have to blast away the existing mind and then insert a new one. The subject was brought to the safehouse at about 10:30 p.m. and was given a casual interview that lasted about an hour. And Im very much afraid of the whole bloody human race. Gottlieb was interested in finding possible new drugs in Nigeria and in the mind-control techniques of Yoruba shamans. Gottlieb and his wife, a fundamentalist Christian, lived on a farm in the Shenandoah Mountains in northern Virginia. Sidney Gottlieb, MKULTRA Mastermind (Credit: CIA) Gottlieb's story begins at James Monroe High School in the Bronx in the 1930s. They were testing a weapon; for their purposes, they might as well have been in a ballistics lab. But the Olson disaster reduced their enthusiasm for self-testing, and so did another mishap that occurred when an unwitting CIA officer had a dose of LSD slipped into his coffee at the Agencys offices on the Mall in Washington, D.C. White claimed he was such an expert in physical combat that he had killed a Japanese agent in a hand-to-hand encounter. Over the next three days, the subject underwent intense interrogation, while CIA doctors gave him intravenous infusions of hallucinogens and placed him under hypnosis. Gottlieb asked White to establish a CIA safehouse in New York, invite suitable subjects to party there, drug them covertly and then review their behavior. The death (or possibly murder) of Frank Olson was but a hint of the enormous secret CIA program of research into techniques of mind alteration and control. The names Fanny Bender Gottlieb and Louis Gottlieb are also cited on . Sidney Gottlieb. In one experiment, a female CIA security officer was hypnotized and provided with a new identity. They had doped up NLF officers with LSD, hoping that by inducing irrational behavior, the seemingly unbreakable solidarity of their captives could be broken and that the other inmates would then begin to talk. Lilly, the Indianapolis-based drug company, succeeded in this endeavor in 1954. Gottliebs colleagues at Army Intelligence were conducting their own experiments with LSD, called Operation Third Chance. A story in which for more than twenty years the CIA paid for such illegal activities, protected criminals from arrest, let others suffer without intervention and tried to destroy all evidence of its crimes? This bizarre foray in behavioral conditioning consisted of the patients being assaulted by verbal messages played on a loop-feed tape player for sixteen hours a day; the speaker was often hidden under a pillow and was designed to deliver the messages subliminally while the patient slept. Major newspapers ran obituaries when he died in 1999. Sidney Gottlieb died on March 7, 1999 at the age of 80. Olson was a 43-year-old civilian germ-warfare researcher for the U.S. Army who was also a CIA employee and an unwitting recipient of CIA acid. Thornwell experienced a major mental crisis from which he never recovered. An international commission in 1952 concluded that the charges had merit. Then there are the endless potions directed at Fidel Castro, from the LSD the Agency wanted to spray in his radio booth to the poisonous fountain pen intended for Castro that was handed by a CIA man to Rolando Cubela in Paris on November 22, 1963. The CIA funded a project at the Childrens International Summer Village. Gottlieb's life after the CIA resembled a quest for atonement. She was suffering from a modest case of post-partem depression and chronic back pains. Sidney Gottlieb, chemist and intelligence officer: born New York 3 August 1918; married 1942 Margaret Moore (two sons, two daughters); died Washington, Virginia 7 March 1999. Posted in Crime, Policy, Science, War | 2 Comments From the fall of 1953 to the late spring of the following year, White hosted a string of parties, inviting a stream of unsuspecting CIA subjects to Bedford Street, spiking their food and drink with chemicals such as sodium pentothal, Nembutal, THC and, of course, what White referred to as the LSD surprise. Whites immediate supervisor in New York was Richard Lashbrook, the man who shared Frank Olsons room on the latters last night on earth. In one case, he claimed that he had created a new personality in a normal Marine. Source: dailytelegraph.com.au, A guinea pig in the LSD experiments. What I really mean is that I hate them. After getting a doctorate in biochemistry from California Institute of Technology in 1940, he married Margaret Moore, who had been born in India. . Only the enemy had changed. I was a vegetable. He coedits the Hitchcock Annual (with Richard Allen), and his books include Hitchcock on Hitchcock: Selected Writings and Interviews, Volume 2; Alfred Hitchcock: Interviews; and Roberto Rossellini's Rome Open City. The Current TikTok Ban Doesnt Go Far Enough. Criminologists revere Allen as a pioneer in the use of the polygraph. This had the double utility of squelching the charges of germ warfare and also of justifying the Bluebird program. The aim was to wipe out the patterns of thought and behavior which were detrimental to the patient and replace them with healthy patterns of thought and behavior, said Dr. Peter Roper, a colleague of Camerons who still defends the experiments. In fact, he taught us all how to read to read between the lines, through the bullshit and beyond the imperial dogma. In one such experiment, three prisoners were anaesthetized; their skulls were then opened and electrodes were implanted by CIA doctors into different parts of their brains. AI Chatbots are Even Scarier Than You Think, DeSantiss Educational Policies Come Right Out of the Fascist Playbook, Erase the Memory to Erase a People? CIA men would often go down to the Tenderloin district, visit bars and slip hallucinogens into patrons drinks. He ran it until it was shut down in the early '60s. Of course Im afraid of them. As a poison expert, he headed the chemical division of the Technical Services . The whole enterprise was assigned the code-name MK-ULTRA and was run out of the CIAs Technical Services Division, headed in the 1950s by Willis Gibbons, a former executive of the US Rubber Company. Afraid of them? Over the next four years, the CIA gave Cameron more than $60,000 for his work in consciousness-alteration and mind control. Less well-known is the handkerchief laced with botulinum that was to sent to an Iraqi colonel. Alexander CockburnsGuillotined! But aside from these pioneering works, how did the American press and historians of the CIA deal with this astonishing saga, in which a man such as Olson lost his life, thousands of people were involuntarily and unknowingly dosed with drugs so dangerous or untested that the CIAs own chemists dared not try them? The New York Medical . At one point his interrogators threatened to extend the state indefinitely, even to a permanent condition of insanity. They consummated this promise. To oversee this operation, Gottlieb turned to George Hunter White, whom we last encountered testing the marijuana truth drug on Mafia muscle man Augusto Del Gracio. I never had the guts to kill myself or Id have got out of it long ago. (Good Morning, Midnight). MK-ULTRA was created on April 13, 1953, when CIA director Allen Dulles approved Helmss proposal to develop the covert use of biological and chemical materials. In fact, CIA chemist Sidney Gottlieb had gone well beyond curare, a toxin that is found in tropical plants. In 1968, in the year of Sidney Gottlieb's passing, on April 4th, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., the civil rights leader, was shot and killed by an assassin in Memphis. In 1982 he was found drowned in his swimming pool in Maryland. Gottlieb's inventiveness also ran to a variety of assassination plots against various foreign targets. Subjects, who included prisoners, mental patients, and prostitutes and their customers, were exposed unwittingly to LSD, and observed for their reactions. Linda McDonald was typical of Camerons victims, who tended to be women. The money for Isbells research was being funneled by the CIA through the National Institutes of Health. Instead, what happened was the great void. And even less well remembered is one mission in the Agencys Phoenix operation in Vietnam in the late 1960s. He made pills, powders, and potions that could kill or maim without a traceincluding . Drug addicts would get cash, drugs or treatment. Ultimately, Sandoz agreed to supply the Agency with 100 grams a week, deny requests from the Soviet Union and China, and also to furnish the Agency with a regular list of its LSD customers. John Le Carre, The Spy Who Came In From the Cold. He perfected a contaminated handkerchief for use against an Iraqi colonel, poisoned presents that were to eliminate the troublesome Fidel Castro, and a poisoned dart designed to get rid of Patrice Lumumba, Communist sympathiser and leader of the Congo. Will California Save the Iconic Joshua Tree? To his enduring disappointment, a club foot barred him from active service in the Second World War . But the CIAs response was to leak to favored reporters at Time, the Chicago Tribune, and the Miami Herald stories to the effect that the American POWs had been brainwashed by their Communist captors. To take one example, in 1953 the CIA became concerned that Sandoz, the Swiss pharmaceutical firm for which Albert Hoffman had developed LSD, was planning to put the drug on the open market. June 30, 2022 . Nothing satisfied Cameron quite like the use of electro-shock therapy, which he believed could wipe the mind clean, allowing him to purge his patients of their disease. These studies indicate that from the CIAs earliest days it has had a keen interest in developing methods of social control over potentially disruptive elements in American society.
Is It Possible To Break A Twin Flame Connection, Skype For Business Contacts Not Showing, Articles H